WebMar 28, 2024 · In his Declaration, Judge Abraham argued that the Court went too far in this context, by giving the “principle of ‘territorial integrity’ a near absolute scope” (Judge Abraham, p. 153). Noting that internal colonial boundaries had often been arbitrarily defined, for example, when the Seychelles were detached from Mauritius in 1903 ... WebJun 2, 2024 · Footnote 32 Judge Xue espoused a seemingly compatible view, lamenting the Court's nontreatment of the respondents' additional preliminary ... Pakistan, RMI v. UK, Declaration of Judge Xue paras. 12–13 (citing the preamble via the Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion). 37 37 SC Res. 984 para. 6 (11 April 1995) (emphasis added). You …
On the Entirely Predictable Outcome of Croatia v. Serbia
WebApr 4, 2024 · Even though Judge Xue’s declaration appears to also indicate doubts as to the Court’s jurisdiction, this is where she really took issue with the majority’s approach . Despite Judge Xue’s expression of regret that the Court’s order as rendered prejudged the jurisdiction and/or merits of the case, her declaration appears to do the same ... WebJul 9, 2024 · The secondary opinions solely disagreed on procedural matters, notably discretion, or the extent of the ruling (Declaration of Judge Tomka, ... That may be true, irrespective of Judge Xue’s declaration to the contrary (para. 14; for more nuance, see Thomas Dale Grant in Allen/Monaghan). Even after the Court’s Opinion, the UK could still ... bisley seat stick
ICJ Order 16 March 2024 (Dec Xue).pdf - DECLARATION OF...
WebApr 21, 2024 · however, I wish to make a few observations in this declaration. 2. First of all, traditional fishing rights are recognized and protected under customary international law. … WebJul 23, 2024 · IN FAVOUR: President Yusuf; Vice-President Xue; Judges Abraham, Bennouna, Cançado Trindade, Sebutinde, Robinson; Judge ad hoc Daudet; ... Judges TOMKA, GAJA and GEVORGIAN append a joint declaration to the Order of the Court; Judge CANÇADO TRINDADE appends a separate opinion to the Order of the Court; … WebDECLARATION OF JUDGE XUE 1. Much to my regret, I have voted against the operative paragraph 1 of the Judgment regarding the Court’s jurisdiction to entertain Croatia’s … darley abbey historical society